top of page
  • Bluesky
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • reddit-icon-white
  • Instagram

Ingrid Garner chats about portraying Vampira actress in A Hollywood Horror Story

2 hours ago
7 min read

A Hollywood Horror Story - Photo Credit: Austin Bauman
Ingrid Garner in A Hollywood Horror Story Photo Credit: Austin Bauman

Most die-hard horror fans know who Vampira was, but you may not know the back story of Maila Nurmi, the woman who portrayed the iconic horror character. Actress Ingrid Garner is out to change that with her passion project, A Hollywood Horror Story, a one-woman show that she wrote and performs.

 

A brief history of Nurmi / Vampira: Originally a performer and pinup model, Nurmi attended a masquerade party in 1953 wearing a costume inspired by the Morticia Addams character in Charles Addams’s cartoons. She caught the eye of tv producer Hunt Stromberg, Jr., and he hired her to host horror movies. She was definitely an arresting figure with her pale skin and a tight black dress that accentuated her 17-inch waist. It’s believed that Nurmi was the model on which Disney’s Sleeping Beauty character Maleficent was based.

 

There is obviously much more to her story, and if you get the opportunity to see A Hollywood Horror Story, I promise you will be fascinated AND entertained. A Hollywood Horror Story has been performed at many Fringe Festivals, and I saw Ingrid’s riveting performance at Orlando Fringe, where she wowed audiences.

 

I had the chance to talk to Ingrid Garner about her successful run of A Hollywood Horror Story.

 

The Horror Lounge: Ingrid, tell me about your background as a performer.


Ingrid Garner: I come from a family of performers, in circus, standup and music, but I was actually intent on becoming a sheep farmer, originally, and studied animal husbandry for a few years. Ultimately, my grades reflected more of an actor.

 

I’ve now spent the last 12 years touring a show I adapted from my Grandmother’s WWII memoir, which I wrote in the last semester of my Theatre Arts education at Cal State Fullerton. It’s taken me all over the US, UK, Canada and Australia! But my theatre roots are actually in horror and comedy. I spent almost 10 years “scare-acting” in stage adaptations of famous B-movies. I died gruesomely in Night of the Living Dead, played ‘Betty Foster’ in Santa Claus Conquers the Martians, and haunted as ‘Vampira’ in Plan 9 from Outer Space.

 

THL: How did A Hollywood Horror Story come to be? Be detailed here. I want to know how you became interested in Maila Nurmi's story, how you managed to capture her mannerisms and look, what the writing and rehearsal process was like, and the evolution of the show.

 

IG: Well, it all started in high school when my Psychology teacher thought I would enjoy Ed Wood’s films, and lent me a bunch of his VHS tapes. So I was introduced to Vampira, like most folks, through his magnum opus, Plan 9 from Outer Space. Funnily enough, in 2012, I was cast as her in a stage adaptation of the film, purely based on my 17” waist at the time, but I was thrilled! I ended up doing that show for years, and the more I learned about the woman under the wig, the more curious I became about how Maila Nurmi could go from being a cultural icon to, only a year later, starring in the kind of B-movie she made a career mocking.

 

In 2016, I created a show called B-Movie Bash, where I played a horror host character named “Macabra” and invited other comedians on stage to roast bad movies live for an audience. Somehow, Maila Nurmi’s friend Jonny Coffin (Vampira’s estate manager) saw those promo photos and reached out. He said he had never seen someone capture Vampira’s physicality like I had before, even though I wasn’t playing Vampira in the photos. We met up that October, and he brought along some incredible memorabilia that mesmerized me (like napkins that James Dean had drawn cartoons of Maila on, and a brochure from Elvis’s first stint in Vegas, where they misspelled his name as “Priestly”).

 

He expressed that he was looking for ways to revitalize her story, but knowing how sensitive she was about who would play her, he didn’t want to have someone be the “New Vampira”. I thought a theatre show would be a good way to accomplish that because, at the end, when the wig comes off, it would be clear that it’s just a performer playing the character. And I thought Maila would be a perfect subject for the stage because she was such a theatrical person. She was a monologist (which is like early stand-up comedy), got her start on Broadway in Mae West’s show Catherine Was Great, and was ultimately brought to Hollywood by Howard Hawks after being discovered in a Spook Show.

 


Ingrid Garner as Maila Nurmi in A Hollywood Horror Story  Image courtesy Ingrid Garner
Ingrid Garner as Maila Nurmi in A Hollywood Horror Story

When I was imagining the show, I latched onto these photos Jonny showed me of Maila getting into the Vampira wig at a vanity. There was something so captivating about watching the metamorphosis, and I envisioned her dressing room as a laboratory where her creature is brought to life. I knew that was going to be the set for a show I saw as a Frankenstein-meets-Cinderella story, in which the audience witnesses Maila Nurmi’s transformation into Vampira live onstage.

 

I decided we should follow Maila’s journey to Vampira, from her humble beginnings as a Depression-era kid born to Finnish immigrant temperance evangelists, feeling like an alien in search of other misfits, and watch how her early role models, jobs, failures and friendships would shape her invention. Each influence is illustrated by removing a piece of Maila’s clothing and adding a piece of Vampira’s costume. (For example: fishnets from her burlesque days, a corset to highlight her feeling stifled by 50s femininity, heels from her pin-up work, etc.)

I wanted this process to culminate in the fateful night she wins first prize at The Bal Caribe masquerade and lands her Horror Host gig. An electrifying “Frankenstein’s Lab” scene where the scraps of her dark idols (The Evil Queen in Snow White, Norma Desmond in Sunset Boulevard, The Addams Family, etc.) are stitched together, and the resulting creature “Vampira” surges to life with a thunder crack and her iconic scream!

 

Creating this show instantly became my dream…but then I just didn’t do it. For ten years. For a decade, insecurity, finances, the pandemic, and civil service kept my pen from the page and filled me with shame. I saw the show so vividly in my head, but was terrified that I lacked the skill to meet my own expectations, let alone those of my fellow Vampira fans. But all that time, I never stopped consuming anything I could find about Maila Nurmi. Not just books, interviews, and films with Vampira, but those about her influences, her friends, and idols.

 

Then, in 2025, my dear friend Erika Macdonald asked if I would secretly fly out and premiere 20 minutes of the show in Cincinnati, as a mystery headliner for her Show Us Your Weird Cabaret. My pals have been hearing me talk about this show for so long, and have told me how excited they are to see it. But that deadline, combined with the lack of pressure to create a final product, is what I really needed to pull the show out of my head.

 

I managed to finish 20 minutes in two weeks of writing, staging, memorizing and finally, in October 2025, Vampira erupted in front of a sold-out cabaret crowd, comprised mostly of fans of my WWII show. What a shock that must have been! I was blown away by the reaction, especially by how emotional folks were at the end (because I hadn’t mentioned anything sad yet). Vampira fans in attendance told me that I had captured what they found so inspiring and relatable about her, especially for misfits in a hostile world. That sentiment helped me figure out what this show is about: the power of individuality as, and the importance of chosen family. Maila knew that standing out wasn’t a flaw, it was a magic power, and Vampira is how she spread that message and finally found her people.

 

Now I’ve spent a year touring the finished show across the U.S. and Canada, and it’s truly been the honor of my afterlife to resurrect this story for fellow Vampira lovers, and also to introduce her to so many new fans, to whom she becomes an instant obsession. But the biggest highlight has been doing the show for comedy legend Dana Gould (The Simpsons, Hanging with Doctor Z), who was Maila’s closest friend at the end of her life. He actually paid for the apartment she passed away in.

 

Dana came up afterwards for a Q&A, and his compliments were of the highest order. He said that I nailed Maila and Vampira, and that he was moved to hear her voice for the first time since she’d passed away. The best reward for a decade of work.

 

THL: What is happening with you/the show in the near future? Is your focus on this show, or do you plan to expand it?

 

IG: I’m having the time of my life with this show and I can’t get enough of sharing it with folks. I want to take it everywhere. Right now I’m working on a 2027 tour, and while I’m applying to my usual festivals, I would also love to bring it to horror conventions and film festivals. The show is pretty flexible. It works great in traditional theaters and movie houses, and can also be pared down easily for little punk spaces. But I would love to develop a longer version, that can be hosted at bigger theaters, with a gorgeous, scaled-up set design!

 

THL: Are you working on anything else currently?

 

IG: When I’m not on the road, I work for Arts Orange County’s Jail Project in Southern California, teaching Creative Writing to incarcerated Military Veterans, Women and LGBT populations. While I don’t have plans yet, I may one day write a show about it. I’ve also considered expanding A Hollywood Horror Story into a franchise, to make shows about other Hollywood fringe characters. Who knows!


For future performance dates of A Hollywood Horror Story, keep an eye on the website.



Comments


bottom of page