top of page
  • Bluesky
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • reddit-icon-white
  • Instagram

The Other Mommy vs Incidents Around the House: A Comparison

3 minutes ago
4 min read

Incidents Around the House by Josh Malerman is a 2024 novel that is told from the perspective of a young narrator, 8-year-old Bela, who lives with her parents she affectionately refers to as Mommy and Daddo. Bela starts mentioning and interacting with a creature that starts in her closet, an otherworldly entity who she refers to as Other Mommy due to its ability to shift its appearance and its early choices to appear as her Mom. The creature seems obsessed with Bela and more importantly, Bela accepting the creature "into her heart," an act of unknown consequences to everyone involved. As the entity becomes more active, it drives the family to the brink of madness and unearths long-buried truths that have been stashed away for far too long.


This year, the novel was picked up for a film adaptation, similarly to Malerman's work over a decade ago with Bird Box. Rob Savage, of Host fame, was tapped to direct and Jessica Chastain to star as both Mommy and many versions of Other Mommy. They also changed the title to the much simpler Other Mommy. They went very heavy into marketing, highlighting the many jump scares throughout in the trailers, but when the reviews flowed in, it became clear that the film adaptation wasn't coming across the same way as the novel. I think there's a clear reason for this.


Other Mommy


The most resounding portion of Incidents Around the House is the perspective coming from an 8-year-old. You realize how simple Bela's worldview is and the things she holds dear, there's a sense of nostalgia because we can all relate to what its like being eight. You also really get a good peek into family dynamics, parenting and how much kids pick up on and internalize. By the end of the novel, it became clear to me that Other Mommy is just a representation of familial strife, of the monsters that our past requires us to keep tucked away under lock and key, and if unaddressed, these monsters can rear their ugly heads down the line and consume what we hold dear.


The idea of Other Mommy can be viewed as many things, which is why it becomes so abundantly relatable for readers. It can be sexual trauma, family secrets, repressed childhood memories, etc. The important part is that Other Mommy weaponizes the past and the secrets to make its way closer to Bela and eventually be "let into her heart," assumedly permanently changing her. Its a beautiful metaphor really, to address your trauma or misgivings before they materialize and hurt the ones you love most.


While there are horrifying moments with Other Mommy, a lot of the feelings that hang with you after finishing the novel are these deep feelings of connection and secrets, of the importance of communication and guiding our kids and young ones, of being better versions of ourselves for those who rely on us. A lot of the fears mirror the fear of parenting, such as how can we protect from things we can't anticipate, how can we know they will make the right decisions when given opportunity, how do we know that we haven't done damage to affect them?


This brings me to the film. The setup is largely the same. I think the sauce was lost a bit when it came to the deeper and more layered themes in this story. There was a massive emphasis on jump scares and weaponizing Other Mommy's abilities of mimicry. While the novel describes Other Mommy in many forms, looking like Jessica Chastain is the main emphasis in the film. There is some play on family dynamics and lost innocence but they are heavily focused to the end and not set up enough.


There was this massive push and marketing buzz about jump scares every so many seconds in this film and when you write and plan for things like that, the human and emotional element really dissolves into the rush for scares and that connection that the viewer is trying to build to the characters is severed. There is so much focus on the entity itself and what its gonna do next, that we miss those complicated dynamics between the parents, we miss the intimate moments of confession and fears of parenthood that are so prevalent in the novel. When you strip these away, the plot becomes simple, a shapeshifting entity trying to get to a little girl. The ending sequence in the novel is profoundly more impactful than the film (I won't spoil it in case you are behind on either). It really drives home the fears that have been silently building and you can analyze the consequences much more clearly.


Overall, I think there was a fundamental disconnect with the filmmakers product and the purpose of Malerman creating this concept. Malerman wanted to speak on parenthood, on the undercurrent of our past and how we can unintentionally force our kids to inherit those mistakes, he wanted to emphasize trauma in youth and the power of an effective family unit. The film wanted to highlight a shape-shifting demon who can look like its lead actress and pump you with as many scares as it can. As a result, we see the hollowness come through on screen while the deeply layered themes of the novel ring around in readers' heads for weeks.



Comments


bottom of page